Colorado Paint Store Encourages Leftover Paint Recycling Through PaintCare Program

by Annie Dameworth | Nov 16, 2026 | Operational Insights

As homeowners clear out garages and basements ahead of the holidays and wrap up fall painting projects, Dream Painting in Aurora, Colorado, is encouraging residents to recycle leftover house paint through Colorado's statewide paint stewardship program, PaintCare.

Dream Painting said many households across the region it serves have years of half-used cans on shelves, much of it left over from past projects and never used again.

According to PaintCare, the nonprofit that operates Colorado's paint stewardship program under oversight of the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, the program began in July 2015 under state law and now lists 225 year-round drop-off sites across Colorado.

PaintCare sites accept house paint as well as primers, stains, sealers and clear coatings such as shellac and varnish, with no charge for dropping off paint at a PaintCare site. The program has collected an estimated 8.4 million gallons in Colorado to date.

"Almost every house we walk into has a stack of old paint cans in the garage," says Kyler Williams, owner of Dream Painting. "Keep a small amount of each color you have on the walls for touch-ups, label it with the room and take the rest to a drop-off site. There's no reason to let it sit for ten years."

The company recommends homeowners planning interior paint projects this winter ask their painter how much paint will be ordered and what will happen to the leftovers, so only what is needed comes home.

Exterior work typically resumes in spring, and the same planning applies, Williams says. Homeowners scheduling exterior projects can save a labeled can of each exterior color for future touch-ups and recycle older products that no longer match the house, the company said.

Ceiling projects often leave behind primers and specialty coatings as well. For homeowners considering projects like popcorn ceiling removal, PaintCare says discussing materials and cleanup ahead of time helps keep unused products from piling up.

"A cleaner garage is a nice side benefit," Williams says. "But mostly it's about not wasting what can be reused and getting old paint out of the house the right way."